Life Is a Miracle (2004)

If you’re excited about America’s 250 birthday and going into Young Washington hoping for a patriotic retelling of the founding of this nation and a celebration of the values that underlie such a founding, you’re going to be sorely disappointed. Although it should somewhat be obvious given the title of the film, Young Washington is actually a retelling of George Washington’s involvement in the French and Indian War. Here is where the problems start.

Telling a story about the French and Indian Wars from the perspective of the British, or at least its colony of Virginia, is a choice to prioritize the perspective of the colonizers of this country.  If Angel Studios had chosen to make this story about the Revolutionary War, at least they could focus on the heroic ideals while ignoring (or, dare they, address?) the lesser ones.  But here, there’s no heroic ideal: the explicit, and only, point of George Washington’s journey in this movie is to further the British conquest of indigenous lands.  That does not celebrate America, that celebrates racism. 

Choosing to prioritize the perspective of the British also serves to diminish the perspective of everyone else.  The French are cartoonishly villainous and stereotypical.  Black people barely appear in the movie, and when they do, their subservience is the whole of their character.  That subservience is portrayed in a way that erases the brutality and grotesqueness of slavery, reducing it to just a background fact.  One Native American is portrayed as smart, while the rest are portrayed as antagonistic and fear-inducing, reinforcing a centuries-old stereotype of indigenous people as “savages.”  Look, this isn’t the 1920s, the non-white people of the film are not portrayed in as awful a light as possible.  There’s an attempt to be respectful, but that attempt seems ill-informed, even ignorant.