Incluvie – Better diversity in movies.
Identity in film with Incluvie stamps, scores, reviews.

Incluvie – Better diversity in movies.
Explore identity in film with Incluvie stamps, scores, reviews, and insights.

"12 Dates of Christmas" Forgos Holiday Cheer in Favor of Formulaic Tedium

The 12 Dates of Christmas does little to reinvent the rom-com wheel at any point.

The 12 Dates of Christmas (2026)

2.0 / 5
PopScore
Incluvie StampIncluvie Stamp
Incluvie Stamps

Hulu’s attempt at Hallmark-style Christmas rom-coms this year starts with the release of The 12 Dates of Christmas. Reuniting Lucy Hale and Ian Harding from “Pretty Little Liars”, The 12 Dates of Christmas follows Christina Walker (Hale) as she goes on twelve dates in the twelve weeks leading up to Christmas to appease her mother (Penelope Ann Miller). Suddenly, her high school crush, Peter Grant (Harding), returns from the big city back to small-town Mississippi to settle down himself, and he asks for Christina’s help in furnishing his new home. As expected, classic holiday rom-com antics ensue. In actuality, the film is nothing like a classic Hallmark holiday rom-com, as it shirks its holiday spirit, any romance, and a lot of the promised comedy. Instead, this film is repetitive, uninspired, and lacking in Christmas magic.

When someone sits down to enjoy a holiday rom-com, there are some non-negotiables. There needs to be a decently believable romance between the leads, a handful of moments that actually encourage laughing out loud, and at least a dash of snow to create the atmosphere of true holiday magic. Unfortunately, The 12 Dates of Christmas entirely disregards that it is a holiday rom-com and excludes almost all of these key factors.

The leads spend less than thirty minutes together onscreen, leaving very little romance to root for in a film about their love story. Instead, the movie leans into the stunt casting by bringing back Lucy Hale and Ian Harding to work on this film together. That marketing decision, of course, referenced the time they played romantic interests on “Pretty Little Liars”, but this stunt casting cannot make up for a lack of key romantic scenes between the two. As a result, the romance is never properly sold.

As for the comedic aspect, it is the strongest aspect of this film, but that does not say much. Unfortunately, the funniest characters in The 12 Dates of Christmas are all featured performers who play Christina’s outrageous dates and only show up for a sequence or two before she abandons them for another extremely repetitive date. To be fair, most of these actors did give it their all, and it does show in the final cut.

In all honesty, the weakest part of this film is that it never feels like a holiday movie in the first place. No part of the story requires the film to be set during Christmastime. The only reason Christina needs a boyfriend by Christmas is that during the previous year’s celebration, her mother berated her for not bringing someone at all. Who is to say that her mother would not do the same during Easter or Thanksgiving? The largest cardinal sin of this film is that, even though it is set in the Northern Hemisphere during winter, no miracle snowstorm appears to give this film a picturesque background to a story of supposed Christmas magic.

For such a formulaic film, luckily there was minimal stereotyping, but there was also minimal depth in its diversity.  The lead couple is white, affluent, and straight, like most American rom-coms. People of color are sidelined to supporting roles like Christina’s best friend, Molly (Kahyun Kim), who is the one who pushes her to go on these dates, which leads to Christina and Peter eventually getting together. This makes The 12 Dates of Christmas another prime example of people of color being used to boost the success of their white peers, especially in rom-coms. To see a film in 2026 fall back on that decades-long trope was disappointing, but not surprising, for a film already embroiled in long-time cinematic tropes.

In such an oversaturated holiday rom-com market, The 12 Dates of Christmas does little to reinvent the wheel at any point. In fact, there is an argument that it could barely call itself a holiday rom-com at all. With very little shared screen time between the romantic leads, it is hard to buy Christina and Peter’s longtime crushes and eventual enamoration with one another. Not to mention, the humorous antics of Christina’s failed dates often come off as cringey rather than hilarious, as she fails to find her beau. But, somehow, worst of all, The 12 Dates of Christmas misses the mark on capturing the season’s magic by leaving viewers out in the snow with nothing of substance to warm their hearts on those cold winter nights.